New Jersey Pizza Co

We decided to try out a new pizza place and were shockingly disappointed. Delivery took 2 hours. Kitchens get busy, so a long wait can be excused as long as the end result is a delicious meal. This was far from it. We each tried a slice and the rest was tossed into the trash. The pizza was so greasy, that when held upright, it dripped onto the plate. Flavor-wise it was very bland and oddly tasted watered down. Maybe their other styles would have been a better choice. We also ordered wings. Thankfully, they were edible. Not great, but edible. They were very dry and tough.

Had really high expectations from all the different reviews. Ended being highly disappointed. Almost an hour wait for food even though only 1 other customer was in there and 2 pickup orders came in. They messed up our order even though there were only 3 toppings between 2 pizzas. Pizza ended up just being ok, crust was burnt. Salad was decent. Definitely wanted more for the price of pizzas ($19 fo 12 inch pizza).

I truly pray that I receive an equally unprofessional response as the last guy who left an HONEST review. Before reading further just know you are better off with the 3 small pizzas from a lunchable. If an owner takes the time out of their day to respond to a review because they got their wittle feelings hurts, it’s because that review had truth. By far the worst food I’ve experienced in my life, and I’ve eaten bugs! This place is expensive and not at all worth it. For 2 16” pizzas and 2 dozen wings the bill came out to $120. Then the delivery itself was a 2 hr wait. At first I didn’t mind the wait because reviews mentioned a long wait but delicious taste. Delivery guy also said that the place is slow but good. Is New Jersey Pizza Co. paying everyone to lie? Or are they holding their families hostage? Did I miss the secret code to receive actual good food? God awful greasy limp pizza. The wings? Tiny, dry and too much vinegar. After everyone had a serving, not that it could be finished, this was all thrown into the trash If you want your tastebuds to be offended and appalled then this is the trash for you. I’m convinced it’s children held captive being forced to cook the pizza because the pizza tastes like its secret ingredient is hatred.

Pizza great! We try NY/NJ pizza everywhere we travel. (Been to 47 states). No place like Jersey Shore, Mario's in Niagara, and a tiny place in Wilkes-Barre, but this place rocks out here in Flagstaff. We will order here again every time we pass. And the customer service was outstanding! Stayed at Little America, and they brought us plates and napkins.

The meats they use on the pizza are tasty but the pie does them no justice. We ordered a 12" and a 16", both two toppings. The 16" was so greasy and limp that you could barely hold it, half of it went to waste. The 12" bottom crust wasn't as soaked, but still dripping everywhere. I'm not sure why it seemed so wet when there didn't appear to be that much cheese or sauce?? We were quoted 35-40min for pickup and it ended up being an hour and 15 minutes. Prices are absurd for what you get. There's other pizza within a mile of this spot that's both better and cheaper.